Treść książki

Przejdź do opcji czytnikaPrzejdź do nawigacjiPrzejdź do informacjiPrzejdź do stopki
16
ChapterI
ninequestions,17
hiscommentaryontheSentencesisformedinasetof
eightquestions.18
Fromtheperspectiveofthepresentbookthemostimportantisaset
ofeightquestionswhichbelongtohiscommentaryonAristotle’sPhysics.
RecentlyJunghasproventhatKilvington’squestionsonthePhysicsper-
fectlytestifytothedispersedtraditionofthiscommentary.Thewhole
setconsistsofeightquestions:onequestionwithanexpositionofthe
Physics,tobefoundinaVaticanmanuscript(Vat.Lat.4353),19asetof
17
Thequestionsareasfollows:Utrumaugmentatiositmotusadquantitatem;Utrum
numeruselementorumsitaequalisnumeroqualitatumprimarium;Utrumexomnibusduobus
elementispossittertiumgenerari;Utrumcontinuumsitdivisibileininfinitum;Utrumomnis
actiositrationecontrarietatis;Utrumomniaelementasintadinvicemtransmutabilia;Utrum
mixtiositmiscibiliumalteratorumunio;Utrumomniacontrariasintactivaetpassivaadin-
vicem;Utrumgeneratiosittransmutatiodistinctaabalteratione.Theyaretobefound,as
acompleteorincompleteset,inthefollowingmss.:Brugia,StedelijkeOpenbare
Bibl.503;Cambridge,Peterhouse195;Erfurt,WissenschaftlicheAllgemeinbib-
liothek,AmplonianaCms8o74;Kraków,BJ648;Paris,BnFlat.6559;Sevilla,
Bibl.Colombina7-7-13.
18
ThecommentaryontheSentencesistobefoundinthefollowinglibraries:Bo-
logna,Bibl.Comunaledell’ArchiginnasioA.985;Brugge,StedelijkeOpenbare
Bibliotheek,Hs.188,Hs503;Erfurt,CA.105;LondonHarley,BritishLi-
brary,3243;Paris,BnFlat.14576,15561;Praha,NárodníKnihovnaČeskéRe-
publiky,Cod.IIIB.10;Wrocław,Bibl.Uniw.,IVF198;Vatican,Vat.lat.4353;
Firenze,Bibl.NationaleCentraleCod.II.II281;Tortosa,Bibl.delaCatedral
ydelCabildodelaSanctísimaIglesiaCatedral,Cod.186.Theeightquestions,
fromms.Bolognaaretitledasfollows:1)UtrumDeussitsuperomniadiligendus;2)
UtrumperoperameritoriaaugeaturhabituscaritatisquoDeusestsuperomniadiligendus;
3)Utrumomniscreaturasitsuaenaturaecertislimitibuscircumscripta;4)Utrumquilibet
actusvoluntatispersemalussitpersealiquid;5)Utrumpeccansmortaliterperinstans
solummereaturpuniriperinfinitainstantiainterpolata;6)Utrumaliquisnisiforteinpoena
peccatipossitesseperplexusinhisquaepertinentadsalutem;7)Utrumomnisactusfactus
extragratiamsitpeccatum;8)Utrumaliquispossitsimulpeccarevenialiteretmererivitam
aeternam.ForadescriptionofthemanuscriptsseeM.Michałowska,uRichard
Kilvingtononthecapacityofcreatedbeings,infnity,andbeingsimultaneously
inRomeandParis.Criticaleditionofquestion3Utrumomniscreaturasitsuae
naturaecertislimitibuscircumscriptafromQuaestionessuperlibrosSententiarumwithan
Introduction”(forthcoming).
19
InmypaperWorksbyRichardKilvington(p.203,n.102)Iclaimedthatonlyfour
questionsonmotionfromtheMarcianalibraryformKilvington’scommentary
tothePhysics.Detailedstudy,however,revealedthatexpositioofthePhysicsas
wellasonequestionnottwo,asIhadclaimedbefore,werealsocomposedby
RichardKilvington.